Sustainability, diversity and safety efforts not awarded with bonuses, UT study reveals – News – CIVIS – Europe’s Civic University Alliance [Skip to content](#main) ![](https://civis.eu/build/assets/circle-09-B3BMjMVU.svg) ![](https://civis.eu/build/assets/circle-11-Bta7Grvo.svg) ![](https://civis.eu/build/assets/circle-06-H_YyMKlQ.svg) [ ![CIVIS – Europe’s Civic University Alliance](https://civis.eu/build/assets/civis-CCpvK1nT.svg)](https://civis.eu/en) - [ Discover ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance) - [ What is CIVIS? ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/what-is-civis) - [ Our work ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work) - [ Mission, Vision & Values ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/mission-vision-values) - [ Governance & Management ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/governance-andamp-management) - [ Who's Who ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/who-is-who) - [ CIVIS Association ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/civis-association) [Open Labs & Civic engagement ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work/open-labs-civic-engagement) - [ Learn ](https://civis.eu/en/learn) - [ Blended Intensive Programmes ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/blended-intensive-programmes) - [ Flexible Learning ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/build-your-learning-path-flexible-offer) - [ Master’s Programmes ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/find-your-master-s-programme) - [ Staff weeks & Job Shadowing ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/keep-on-learning-with-staff-weeks-andamp-job-shadowing) - [ Study abroad ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/study-abroad-and-connect-with-civis-universities) [Discover the projects led by our students in 2025-2026 ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work/student-led-projects/discover-the-projects-led-by-our-students-in-2025-2026) [CIVIS Museum University Forum ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work/CIVIS-Museum-University-Forum) - [ Teach ](https://civis.eu/en/teach) - [ Calls for Projects ](https://civis.eu/en/teach/civis-calls) - [ Innovate your Teaching ](https://civis.eu/en/teach/innovate-your-teaching) - [ Resources for Educators ](https://civis.eu/en/teach/resources-for-educators) [CIVIS BIPs: strong impact and high satisfaction, new report finds ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/civis-bips-strong-impact-and-high-satisfaction-new-report-finds) [Musicians from all over CIVIS come together in Rome to promote inclusiveness ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/musicians-from-all-over-civis-come-together-in-madrid-to-promote-inclusiveness) - [ Research ](https://civis.eu/en/providing-the-tools-for-innovative-research) - [ Research Collaboration ](https://civis.eu/en/providing-the-tools-for-innovative-research/research-collaboration) - [ Careers, Networks & Mobilities ](https://civis.eu/en/providing-the-tools-for-innovative-research/research-careers-networks-and-projects) - [ Resources for Researchers ](https://civis.eu/en/providing-the-tools-for-innovative-research/resources-for-researchers) [CIVIS launches new job space for early-stage researchers across Europe and Africa ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/connecting-talent-with-opportunities-civis-launches-new-job-space-to-connect-early-stage-researchers-across-europe-and-africa) [Facing Common Challenges, Shaping Joint Solutions for Africa and Europe ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/facing-common-challenges-shaping-joint-solutions-for-africa-and-europe) - [ Connect ](https://civis.eu/en/connect) - [ Newsletters ](https://civis.eu/en/connect/newsletters) - [ CIVIS Days ](https://civis.eu/en/connect/civis-days) - [ Civil Society ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work/open-labs-civic-engagement) - [ Contact us ](https://civis.eu/en/contact) - [ Press Corner & Branding ](https://civis.eu/en/connect/press-corner-branding-toolkit) [Make Some Waves: CIVIS Launches New Podcast Series ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/make-some-waves-civis-launches-new-podcast-series) [Fake It Till You News It: Challenges and Solutions in Modern Media Student Innovation Forum ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work/student-led-projects/discover-the-projects-led-by-our-students-in-2025-2026/civis-creathon-contest) [ Our stories ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom) en - [ de ](https://civis.eu/de/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ fr ](https://civis.eu/fr/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ el ](https://civis.eu/el/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ it ](https://civis.eu/it/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ es ](https://civis.eu/es/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ sv ](https://civis.eu/sv/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ ro ](https://civis.eu/ro/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) Menu - [Discover](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance) [ Toggle submenu ](#primary-nav-sm-collapse-29) - [ What is CIVIS? ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/what-is-civis) - [ Our work ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work) - [ Mission, Vision & Values ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/mission-vision-values) - [ Governance & Management ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/governance-andamp-management) - [ Who's Who ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/who-is-who) - [ CIVIS Association ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/civis-association) - [Learn](https://civis.eu/en/learn) [ Toggle submenu ](#primary-nav-sm-collapse-30) - [ Blended Intensive Programmes ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/blended-intensive-programmes) - [ Flexible Learning ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/build-your-learning-path-flexible-offer) - [ Master’s Programmes ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/find-your-master-s-programme) - [ Staff weeks & Job Shadowing ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/keep-on-learning-with-staff-weeks-andamp-job-shadowing) - [ Study abroad ](https://civis.eu/en/learn/study-abroad-and-connect-with-civis-universities) - [Teach](https://civis.eu/en/teach) [ Toggle submenu ](#primary-nav-sm-collapse-31) - [ Calls for Projects ](https://civis.eu/en/teach/civis-calls) - [ Innovate your Teaching ](https://civis.eu/en/teach/innovate-your-teaching) - [ Resources for Educators ](https://civis.eu/en/teach/resources-for-educators) - [Research](https://civis.eu/en/providing-the-tools-for-innovative-research) [ Toggle submenu ](#primary-nav-sm-collapse-32) - [ Research Collaboration ](https://civis.eu/en/providing-the-tools-for-innovative-research/research-collaboration) - [ Careers, Networks & Mobilities ](https://civis.eu/en/providing-the-tools-for-innovative-research/research-careers-networks-and-projects) - [ Resources for Researchers ](https://civis.eu/en/providing-the-tools-for-innovative-research/resources-for-researchers) - [Connect](https://civis.eu/en/connect) [ Toggle submenu ](#primary-nav-sm-collapse-33) - [ Newsletters ](https://civis.eu/en/connect/newsletters) - [ CIVIS Days ](https://civis.eu/en/connect/civis-days) - [ Civil Society ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work/open-labs-civic-engagement) - [ Contact us ](https://civis.eu/en/contact) - [ Press Corner & Branding ](https://civis.eu/en/connect/press-corner-branding-toolkit) [ Our stories ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom) en - [ de ](https://civis.eu/de/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ fr ](https://civis.eu/fr/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ el ](https://civis.eu/el/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ it ](https://civis.eu/it/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ es ](https://civis.eu/es/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ sv ](https://civis.eu/sv/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) - [ ro ](https://civis.eu/ro/the-civis-newsroom/sustainability-diversity-efforts-not-awarded-with-bonuses-ut-study-reveals) 1. [The CIVIS Newsroom ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom) 2. Sustainability, diversity and safety efforts not awarded with bonuses, UT study reveals Sustainability, diversity and safety efforts not awarded with bonuses, UT study reveals ========================================================================================= CIVIS Highlights 13 January 2025 A study by an international team of researchers from the University of Tübingen and the HEC business school in Paris has shown that the payment of bonuses to executive board members in large European corporations is only minimally influenced by whether the top executives made decisions to reduce emissions, increase diversity in the company or improve product safety in the past financial year. According to the study, just 5% of executives’ performance-related remuneration is linked to binding criteria for measuring sustainable corporate behaviour. ![](/storage/files/ut-highlight.png) The researchers evaluated a data set on the remuneration of 674 executives at 73 companies listed in the two major European stock market indices EUROSTOXX 50 and STOXX Europe 50. The data covers the period from 2013 to 2020. However, [the study](https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4974204) also found that 60% of executives had integrated at least one of the ESG (environment, social, governance) criteria into their remuneration. > *Companies, investors and regulators are increasingly promoting the potential of these metrics in executive remuneration to align the interests of executives with broader societal goals, such as environmental protection and diversity. To do this, they would also have to provide real financial incentives. But they don't, because ESG performance metrics are largely symbolic. So, for most companies, appearances are more important than real actions,”* says Professor Patrick Kampkötter, co-author of the study and Head of the Managerial Accounting Department at the University of Tübingen. The researchers distinguished between *binding* and *discretionary* ESG indicators, enabling them to analyse whether the incentives are effective or not. - *Binding metrics* are included in board members’ remuneration contracts at the beginning of the financial year, with a fixed weighting and providing clear and reliable targets. If executives meet or exceed these targets, they receive a payout based on the predetermined weighting of those metrics. - *Discretionary ESG metrics*, on the other hand, are more flexible. Supervisory boards or compensation committees can adjust the weight or importance of these metrics at the end of the fiscal year as they see fit, creating uncertainty about the extent to which an executive's ESG performance affects his or her compensation. As a result, executives may feel less pressured to prioritise these goals throughout the year. Large companies, particularly in the financial sector, often have a variety of largely discretionary ESG metrics in their compensation plans but lack significant weightings, according to the study. > *This combination suggests that for many companies, the inclusion of ESG metrics may be a form of greenwashing - signalling commitment to sustainability without actually promoting substantive improvements or sacrificing shareholder value. As in practice, non-ESG performance metrics such as financial results or share price development, continue to dominate the calculation of executive bonuses”,* says Professor Matthias Efing of the HEC business school in Paris and co-author of the study. Implications for policy and practice ------------------------------------ Professor Patrick Kampkötter underlines that for ESG metrics to drive real business change, they need to stop being a side note in remuneration plans and become a central part of how executives are assessed and rewarded. Thus, investors and regulators could play a crucial role in pushing companies towards more robust ESG remuneration systems. The researchers also stressed that greater transparency on the true weight of ESG metrics and clearer reporting standards would help ensure that companies are held accountable for their ESG commitments to both shareholders and the public. **Read more in the original** [**story, in German**](https://uni-tuebingen.de/universitaet/aktuelles-und-publikationen/pressemitteilungen/newsfullview-pressemitteilungen/article/nachhaltigkeit-kein-wichtiges-kriterium-bei-der-verguetung-von-top-managern/)**.** ### Latest news: [*Romanian researchers discover part of a “graveyard of mammoths” in the Buzău Valley*](https://civis.eu/en/get-informed/news/romanian-researchers-discover-graveyard-mammoths-Buzau-valley) [*Tackling the health challenge through education & research - CIVIS special feature*](https://civis.eu/en/get-informed/news/tackling-the-health-challenge-through-education-and-research) [*Stockholm Prize in Criminology awarded to practitioners working to reduce cruel and unusual punishment*](https://civis.eu/en/get-informed/news/stockholm-prize-criminology-awarded-practitioners-reduce-cruel-and-unusual-punishment) [*Master's Programme in Transdisciplinary Studies of Climate, Environment and Energy*](https://civis.eu/en/learn/find-your-master-s-programme/master-s-programme-in-transdisciplinary-studies-of-climate-environment-and-energy) Related news ------------ - [ ![](https://civis.eu/storage/files/exu-pollmann1-full-800x600.jpg?token=99c089f73cbbe9f8a96db2beb92b7cbe)University of Tübingen retains its status as a University of Excellence under the German government’s Excellence Strategy CIVIS Highlights 20 April 2026 ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/university-of-tubingen-retains-its-status-as-a-university-of-excellence-under-the-german-government-s-excellence-strategy) - [ ![](https://civis.eu/storage/files/wildcat-800x600.jpg?token=feab63e2e638099acac5ba09fdaf86b2)Human activity is influencing the behavior of Germany’s wildcats CIVIS Highlights 16 March 2026 ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/human-activity-is-influencing-the-behavior-of-germany-s-wildcats) - [ ![](https://civis.eu/storage/files/litter2-simontaal-800x600.jpg?token=0e55d70613b6069956c6e9518fb72207)Litter in the Rhine River: some 53,000 items of litter flow past Cologne daily CIVIS Highlights 4 February 2026 ](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/litter-in-the-rhine-river-some-53-000-items-of-litter-flow-past-cologne-daily) [Discover all our stories](https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom) [ Impressive haul of meteorites brought back by Belgian-led team that includes ULB researchers ](< https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/impressive-haul-of-meteorites-brought-back-by-belgian-led-team-of-researchers >) [ Tackling the health challenge through education & research ](< https://civis.eu/en/the-civis-newsroom/tackling-the-health-challenge-through-education-and-research >) ![CIVIS – Europe’s Civic University Alliance](https://civis.eu/build/assets/civis-CCpvK1nT.svg) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Europe’s Civic University Alliance ![Co-funded by the European Union](https://civis.eu/build/assets/co-funded-by-the-european-union-DSKLW1us.png)Views and opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Education and Culture Executive Agency (EACEA). Neither can be held responsible for them. ### People - [ Students ](https://civis.eu/en/i-am-a-student) - [ Academics & researchers ](https://civis.eu/en/i-am-an-academic-researcher) - [ Administrators ](https://civis.eu/en/i-am-an-administrator) - [ Civil society ](https://civis.eu/en/discover-civis-alliance/our-work/open-labs-civic-engagement) - [ Press corner & Branding ](https://civis.eu/en/connect/press-corner-branding-toolkit) ### Useful links - [ Resources ](https://civis.eu/en/resources) - [ CIVIS Agora ](https://civis.eu/en/civis-agora-the-operational-hub-of-the-civis-digital-campus) - [ European Universities initiative ](https://civis.eu/en/european-universities-initiative) - [ Past Events ](https://civis.eu/en/past-events) - [ Contact ](https://civis.eu/en/contact) [Newsletters](https://civis.eu/en/connect/newsletters) ### Social networks - [ ![](https://civis.eu/storage/files/instagram.svg) Instagram ](https://www.instagram.com/civis.eu/) - [ ![](https://civis.eu/storage/files/linkedin.svg) LinkedIn ](https://www.linkedin.com/company/civis-eu) - [ ![](https://civis.eu/storage/files/facebook.svg) Facebook ](https://www.facebook.com/CIVISEuropeanUniversity/) - [ ![](https://civis.eu/storage/files/youtube.svg) YouTube ](https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdCm0FfreX81BuNH-znlRGQ) © 2026 – CIVIS – All rights reserved - [ Cookie Policy ](https://civis.eu/en/cookie-policy) - [ Privacy policy ](https://civis.eu/en/privacy-policy) Website by [Typi Design](https://typi.be) • Design by [Atelier Milky](https://ateliermilky.com) [ ](#top) Search